First Prize Mike's: A Timeless Hot Dog Haven in Schenectady
First Prize Mike's, located at 1135 Erie Blvd in Schenectady, NY, has been a beloved local hotspot since 1947. Known for its classic American diner charm, this eatery specializes in delightful hotdogs topped with mustard, onions, and a rich meat sauce. Patrons rave about the friendly service and affordable menu options. With its fast service, fresh coffee, and a choice between dining in and takeout, First Prize Mike's has become a community favorite. From generous portions of crispy fries to their signature Mike's dogs and burgers, this gem offers a deliciously nostalgic dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
First Prize Mike's at a glance
- Address 1135 Erie Blvd, Schenectady, NY 12305, United States
- Phone +1 518-382-9213
- Restaurant type Hot dog restaurant , Fast food restaurant , Restaurant .
- Popular for Popular for breakfast , Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .
Photos & Gallery
Popular Menu Items
The All the Way Hot Dog Comes with Mustard Meat Sauce and Diced Onion
Hot Dog All the Way
Hand Cut French Fries
Steak Sandwich
Strawberry Milkshake
Lemonade
Scrambled Eggs Side of Home Fries and Wheat Toast
2 Dogs All the Way with Small Onion Rings
Hot Dog with Mustard Hot Dog with the Works
Cheeseburger with Onion Rings
First Prize Mike's: Reviews & Ratings
First Prize Mike's is defiantly a restaurant that is worth trying. Their hotdogs with mustard, onions, and meat sauce are very good. They have been in business since 1947 and it is a well known spot in Schenectady. Service is very fast and friendly. Good meals can be had here at affordable prices. The restaurant serves fresh coffee, but only has a vending machine for soda or water. You can eat in or takeout. If in the area stop by for some food at a well known local spot.
Epitome of a classic hot dog joint. Simple good food. We got there at a slow time so our party of 6 was able to sit right away but right after we ordered it got very busy. Service may have been slow for some but the server was extremely friendly and working hard. Meat sauce was good. Onion rings great. Everything was hot and fresh. Large French fry order was huge!
We have wanted to stop in here for so long and today was finally did. We walked in and were greeted by the sweetest woman! She made us feel like family. The food was incredible - prices were even better! We got the mikes dogs and cheese burger with curly fries and we ate every crumb. The staff was so friendly and thanked us more than once for coming in. There’s no place like this place! We cannot wait to come back.
Our family has been coming here on and off for several years and it’s always a great experience! Today was no different,in fact we will be coming back more frequently! So friendly,accommodating and the food is absolutely delicious and affordable in this crazy economy.
I had another place in mind for my layover but they were closed today and I stopped here instead. Wow! I’m blown away at the quality of food for the cost. Great burger, really good dog (sauce has a hint of spice but not much) and hand cut fries exactly like expected a little crispy and delicious!! I can’t wait for my next layover at Amtrak so I can eat here again! Classic American diner wins again!
The service is absolutely deplorable. Their servers besides one older lady are very rude and talk to you as if you’re a problem. A simple request such as a little extra cheese sauce sent this server in a tizzy and tried charging an extra dollar… place has gone down hill. It’s says a lot when the cooks are the most polite people in the joint.
First Prize Mike's is not your typical fancy dining spot with elaborate tables and silverware, but what it lacks in upscale ambiance, it more than makes up for in serving the best hot dogs in New York. Their hot dogs are a must-try, especially when ordered with their incredible secret sauce, and don't forget to pair them with their delicious fries topped with the same sauce. Despite its humble setting, this place exudes friendliness - from the welcoming servers to the hardworking cook who flawlessly manages a busy kitchen while still greeting guests with a warm smile. The outstanding food truly sets First Prize Mike's apart, making it a unique find within a 100-mile radius. If you're a hot dog enthusiast, don't miss out on the experience at Prize Mike's - you'll be pleasantly surprised.
We used Mike's food truck for a graduation party. It was a big hit, and we couldn't be happier. The set up was prefect; the menu simple but so good. The servers were pleasant and helpful. Schenectadians in the crowd loved it. If you're looking for a good idea for your party, this is it.
Location
-
First Prize Mike's1135 Erie Blvd, Schenectady, NY 12305, United States Hotline: +1 518-382-9213
Welcome to First Prize Mike's, a beloved culinary gem nestled in Schenectady, NY, since 1947. This classic eatery, located at 1135 Erie Blvd, is renowned for its simple yet delightful fare that highlights the essence of American comfort food. Known primarily for its mouthwatering hotdogs, First Prize Mike's takes pride in serving dishes that offer both exceptional flavor and undeniable nostalgia.
Upon stepping inside, you’re greeted with a warm atmosphere and friendly staff that make you feel like part of the family. The hotdogs are the true stars here, particularly when topped with mustard, onions, and a signature meat sauce that adds a flavorful twist. Many patrons rave about how this classic combination embodies the spirit of a traditional hot dog joint. Add some crispy onion rings and hand-cut fries to your order, and you have yourself an unforgettable meal.
Customers like Ryan Mazierski and Jessica Marlow have praised not only the quality of food but also the swift and accommodating service. It’s evident that the staff is dedicated to providing an excellent dining experience, even during peak hours. You might find a line of eager diners but rest assured, the friendly servers are working hard to keep the momentum going.
First Prize Mike's is not just about the food; it’s about the experience. Jillian Leblanc captures this sentiment perfectly, reflecting on how her visit felt more like dining with family than just a meal at a restaurant. The affordable pricing paired with the generous portions ensures that everyone leaves satisfied and eager to return. And as Kelly Hegney notes, this establishment is even more impressive given the current economic climate.
For those looking for a quick bite on the go or a cozy spot to enjoy a meal, First Prize Mike’s offers both dine-in and takeout options. While they serve fresh coffee, soda lovers should note the limited choices—only available from vending machines. Nevertheless, it hardly detracts from the experience; the focus here remains on delivering quality comfort food that warms the heart.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by this iconic spot. With its rich history, welcoming ambiance, and delectable offerings, First Prize Mike’s is indeed a first prize in the world of casual dining!
Business Information
- Accessibility
- Has wheelchair-accessible car park
- Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Has wheelchair-accessible seating
- Service options
- On-site services available
- Offers takeaway
- Serves dine-in
- Delivery
- Payments
- Accepts credit cards
- Accepts debit cards
- Accepts NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards